Hillsdale's Favorite Bakery & Coffee House

Baked with
love & craft

Every pastry tells a story. At Twisted Sisters, we handcraft each batch with locally sourced ingredients, time-honored techniques, and a whole lot of heart — right here in the heart of Hillsdale.

Explore Our Menu Find Us
Artisan pastries and coffee arranged on a rustic wooden table
100%
Handcrafted Daily
Local
Ingredients Sourced
6am–4pm
Fresh Daily
Warm interior of Twisted Sisters Coffee House with wooden counters and baked goods on display
Baker's hands dusting flour on freshly shaped pastry dough
Est. Hillsdale, NY
Our Story

Two sisters. One
shared passion.

Twisted Sisters Coffee House was born from a simple belief: that the best things in life are made slowly, by hand, and shared generously. What started as weekend baking sessions between sisters has grown into Hillsdale's most beloved gathering spot.

Every croissant is laminated at dawn. Every loaf is sourdough, started from our own culture. Every cup of coffee is roasted to order and poured with care. We don't rush. We don't cut corners. We just bake — the way our grandmothers taught us, with patience and pride.

Locally sourced dairy & produce
Small-batch, made-to-order pastries
Single-origin & house-roasted coffee
Vegan & gluten-friendly options
Visit Us

Come for the
coffee, stay for the warmth

We're tucked into a quiet corner of Hillsdale — easy to find, impossible to forget. Pull up a chair, browse the shelves, and let the smell of fresh bread pull you in.

Address

329 White Hill Ln
Hillsdale, NY 12529

Hours

Mon–Fri: 6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Sat–Sun: 7:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Get in Touch

We'd love
to hear from you

Whether you have a question about catering, want to place a custom order, or just want to say hello — drop us a line. We read every message and reply within 24 hours.

We'll never share your information. Reply time: within 24 hours.

Is this your business?This is my business